Around 110 pieces from his collection have been recovered, leaving another 60 unaccounted for, presumed destroyed. His collection included: (* for those that are presumed destroyed, ** for those that are known to be destroyed)
- Pieter Brueghel the Younger - Cheat Profiting From His Master**, cut with scissors
- Antoine Watteau - Two Men*
- François Boucher - Sleeping Shepherd**, which Breitwieser kept by his pillow and his mother put in the garbage disposal[4]
- Corneille de Lyon - Madeleine of France, Queen of Scotland**, garbage disposal
- David Teniers - The Monkey's Ball**, shredded with scissors
A Swiss police officer said, "[N]ever have so many old masters been destroyed at the same time."